My breakdown of this “First World” option of E-Learning:
Benefits:
- Saves
space. Many schools and classrooms are over impacted. With Elearning or
Online Learning, more people can take advantage of education and not be
limited by space issues or constraints.
- Students
can participate in the class in the comfort of their chosen surroundings,
i.e. library, coffee shop, home in pajamas, etc.
- Students
can take a class or a whole program from a school that is located anywhere
in the nation. This opens wide a wealth of opportunity and choices.
- The
learning materials for the class are often of a technology nature, saving
money on physical books, and using resources that can be reviewed over and
over unlike a one time given lecture.
- In an
Asynchronous class students can move at their own pace.
Draw Backs:
- Asynchronous
learning can lend itself too easily to procrastination and therefore
stress induced learning for those that are not as personally motivated or
who are already extremely busy.
- With
Synchronous Learning everyone sees your immediate work (when you type)
which does not give you an opportunity to make corrections, i.e. spelling
or grammar. There is also
little or no time to process information because an immediate response is
expected.
- There
is little to no interaction with other class members and never personal
relationship building with classmates or the professor.
- Discussions
online take much longer than communicating face to face, therefore
professors and students are not able to cover nearly as much content in
the same amount of time online as you can face to face. In fact Ned Kock who wrote ‘Media
Richness or Media Naturalness? The Evolution of Our Biological
Communication Apparatus And It’s Influence On Our Behavior Toward
E-Communication Tools’ estimates that “an exchange of 600 words requires
about 6 minutes for complex
group tasks in face-to-face settings, while exchanging the same number of
words over email or chat would take approximately one hour.”
I suppose I am “old school” as I still would much prefer the
face-to-face version of learning, mostly for the personal interaction and real
time instruction and assistance. But after review of a few articles reporting
the benefits and the concerns of Asynchronous and Synchronous learning, I
definitely see the wisdom in finding a “blended” format. That sounds like a copout perhaps but,
while I truly find both options intriguing and somewhat beneficial, I know I
need the discipline of having to submit work by deadlines but I also like the
idea of working at my own pace to take in the content.
I agree that Blended environments are a great way to meet in the middle and find some blend between traditional classroom and classrooms that are completely online. Like social media I feel that completely online classrooms loose the personal touch of the teacher and can lead to a less desirable learning environment.
ReplyDeleteHaving taken just a few online classes I admit that there might be teachers who are able to bring their personal touch to their digital classroom, but I haven't found one yet.
I think that students are going to benefits from either approach. Because we all learn differently, there is not one way that is going to work better than another. That's the challenge of teaching. There are students who do great with what we know as the traditional teaching approach. While other would benefit greatly with a work at your own pace setting. With the web and all the online resources, many jobs today allow people to work from many different locations such as the home, local coffee shop,or your office.
ReplyDelete